>16th Street Metrobus Line (ridership data)

>

WMATA recently announced that they’re going to be looking into improving bus service on 16th Street NW in DC. There’s another public meeting on September 23, be sure to visit the Metrobus 16th Street Line page for details.

They’ve already had one public meeting (PDF) on July 15, and the attendees broke into small groups to discuss the current problems with the route (mostly bus crowding, bunching, schedule adherence and travel speed issues). According to a recent Washington Post article, Metrobus operates about 75% “on-time” for all routes, defined as between two minutes early and seven minutes late. I’m working with WMATA to get line-specific information for all lines. There’s probably a high amount of variability between lines.

I have some observations about Metrobus operation in general and this line in particular, based on looking at the ridership data I received from WMATA.

There are places along the line where there is low ridership as well as close stop placement. For example, why are there bus stops at Webster, Allison and Buchanan? Could the stop at Allison (ridership of 46 per weekday) be eliminated? Dit speed up a bus line more to eliminate a stop that has extremely low ridership, like at 16th & Leegate (12 riders per day, in the northern portion), or to combine two moderate-ridership stops like 16th at Newton and Oak Streets (ridership about 380 per day, each).

Something that would likely increase average speed and reduce bus bunching would be to shift some of the Metrobus lines to “proof of payment” systems. With this, people riding the bus are required to purchase a ticket off of the vehicle, or to posses a valid pass or transfer. According to the public meeting report, 27% of riders board with a flash pass, and 22% of riders are boarding with a free bus transfer. Occasional random inspections and hefty fines would be required to keep people honest, but on the whole this would speed buses tremendously, because people who had valid fares could board by any door. If half of the riders have already paid, why make them enter through the front door?

Another thing I’ve seen (one example was in Amsterdam’s streetcar system) was to put a one-way gate at the front of the vehicle. This was just a spring-loaded gate with a “do not enter sign” on the back, that encouraged people to use the rear door to exit. It didn’t impede boarding the car, because you just pushed it aside. Exiting through the front door was possible (just pull the gate toward you), but it reminded people that the front door was for entering, and to use the rear door instead.

Last, they could replace the line or one of its “sisters” (there are parallel lines on Georgia Avenue as well as 14th Streets, I believe) with a streetcar. Streetcars accelerate faster and can hold more people, are usually set up for multiple-door boarding, and can be connected together in multiple-car consists, further boosting capacity.

The data from WMATA concerning northbound daily total ridership is presented in the Google Map below. Each place marker is labeled with the total boardings and alightings for that stop.

Color coding is shown on the map:

  • Red 500+ per day
  • Yellow 250-500 per day
  • Green 100-250 per day
  • Blue <100 per day

Enjoy the data. This one took me awhile to enter into Google Maps.

http://maps.google.com/maps/ms?ie=UTF8&hl=en&s=AARTsJrWVV58MZVFD_mJqdxj2-FQTe5PjQ&msa=0&msid=111188381960074250249.000456fb13a80a16dce48&ll=38.947928,-77.034416&spn=0.160205,0.137329&z=12&output=embed
View Larger Map

Advertisements

About perkinsms

I'm an engineer and father interested in transit, parking and economics.
This entry was posted in bus, calculations, dc, transit. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to >16th Street Metrobus Line (ridership data)

  1. Michael says:

    >Well, I’d like to edit my post but I can’t. I updated the color coding to break out the data even more. Key is on the map.

  2. Tom Aloisi says:

    >wow, impressive! Care to tackle the X2 stops? It’s horribly over crowded during rush hour, and many people, including me, have abandoned it all together.

  3. Michael says:

    >I have the X2 data from WMATA and can do it when I get the chance. It takes me about 2-3 hours to input all the data. The S2/4 was more timely since there’s the public meeting. The X2 is being considered for a streetcar upgrade, which I fully support.

  4. Michael says:

    >It’s up. This was a simpler line so it only took me an hour.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s